Traffic, thin walls, a neighbor’s television: anyone who sleeps light buys their first box of earplugs sooner or later. They buy the second box because the first pair did not stay in. We wore twenty pairs for ten weeks, night after night, and the ranking came down to which pair was still there in the morning.
See our #1 ›
Still comfortable after eight hours, side sleeping included. The plug sits inside the ear canal and nothing protrudes toward the pillow — and that is what separates it from the rest of the field.
✓ Sold by BOLLSEN · free shipping over $39 · 40-day returns
At night it is not attenuation that decides it. It is whether you take them out at two in the morning.
Most of our testers sleep on their side, and that is where a protruding stem or ring presses into the pillow. Eleven of the twenty pairs came out mid-night, usually within the first two hours. Every one of those models had a respectable number on the box.
So we scored comfort after two hours, staying in until morning and reusability. Attenuation was a requirement here, not a criterion: a model without a measured figure did not enter the ranking at all.
Yes. The plug quiets everything by roughly the same amount and does not pass high tones selectively — if anything it takes most off the high end. Your alarm wakes you because it is loud and right beside your head.
Comfortable on your side too, and that is exactly where almost everything else fails.
See our #1 ›Through ten weeks of nights — a street-facing bedroom, a thin-walled apartment, hotel rooms — the BOLLSEN Life+ were the only pair our testers left in until morning.
An earplug you pull out at midnight blocks zero decibels after midnight.
The tapered body with two flanges closes flush with the ear. No stem, no ring, so there is nothing to catch when you roll onto your side. That was the cleanest difference in the whole test.
24 dB to EN 352-2. Traffic and voices through a wall fall away to quiet background noise, and the alarm still gets through because it is loud and sounding right beside your ear.
Up to 100 uses, washable in lukewarm soapy water. Worn nightly the cost works out at a few cents a night, against disposable foam counted by the piece.
Ten weeks of nights. Still the same pair.
See our #1 ›The only pair that stayed comfortable for eight hours on the side, and that testers did not remove in their sleep.
| Rated on | Life+ | Rooth | Foam | Alpine | Wax | Loop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comfortable on your side | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ~ | ~ | ✗ |
| Still in by morning | ✓ | ✓ | ~ | ~ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Reusable and washable | ✓ | ~ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ |
✓ meets · ~ partly · ✗ does not meet — based on the pros and cons in the cards above; tap a card to open it.
See our #1 ›We bought twenty pairs at retail and wore them nightly for ten weeks: in a street-facing bedroom, in a thin-walled apartment and in hotels. Every morning we logged whether they were still in. Not one pair came from a manufacturer.
The winner’s attenuation was measured by an independent German laboratory to EN 352-2: 24 dB overall, of which 24 dB at high tones, 21 dB at mid and 19 dB at low. It is a passive plug with no electronics: it lowers the volume, it does not close the ear. Results vary from person to person and depend on how you insert them.
TrustScore comparison · 7 September 2026
Trustpilot gives every company it lists a TrustScore out of 5 and a rating band. We looked up the branded reusable earplugs that appear in our tests. Only one of them reaches the top band, Excellent.
| Rank | Brand | TrustScore |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | BOLLSEN Hearing Protection | 4.3Excellent |
| 2 | Alpine Hearing Protection | 4.1Great |
| 3 | Flare Audio | 4.0Great |
| 4 | Loop Earplugs | 3.6Average |
Excellent starts at 4.3 on Trustpilot. A perfect 5.0 usually means a company has collected very few ratings, so one more review moves the score. BOLLSEN is the only brand here that reaches it, on a profile you can open and check yourself.
Method. TrustScores read from each brand’s public Trustpilot profile on 7 September 2026. Where a brand runs several country profiles, we used the one with the most reviews, so every row shows a global profile rather than a local one. Brands with fewer than 250 reviews are not shown. Star ratings are the ones Trustpilot displays, rounded to the nearest half star. Trustpilot bands: Excellent 4.3 to 5.0, Great 3.8 to 4.2, Average 3.0 to 3.7. Scores change as new reviews come in. Compiled independently by US Consumer Review Company. Not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by Trustpilot.